Upper West Side neighbors Charles, Oliver & Mabel bond over a shared love of true crime. When a fellow resident dies in their building, the trio determine to solve the mystery and record an accompanying podcast.
The group begins researching the victim. Meanwhile, Mabel’s secretive past starts to be unraveled.
Oliver employs his theater director skills to analyze the case. Charles & Mabel question an obsessive cat lover.
Believing the murderer might be a famous resident whom is difficult to access, the group seeks advice from a renowned podcasting host.
Mabel slips away on a solo mission tracking the victim’s final days. Suspicious, Charles & Oliver follow her.
Mabel brings her new friends (and an old one) to her childhood home to meet her mother. Meanwhile, Detective Williams starts to have her own doubts about the case as she prepares for motherhood.
With the investigation scratching at a web of old crimes originating inside the building, a mysterious young man turns the tables to spy on Charles, Oliver & Mabel.
Hitting a dead end, the group calls for reinforcements in the form of their podcast’s Superfans.
With the residents growing upset at the building’s negative publicity, the trio faces a revolt. Charles is visited by an old colleague who sheds light on his past.
The trio races toward a resolution while their own lives are put in danger.
Welcome home, Arconiacs! Minutes after Season 1’s finale, Charles, Oliver and Mabel are now implicated in the murder of Board President, Bunny Folger. They must choose whether to lay low or risk their safety by catching the killer themselves.
Watch out for knitting needles and check out Elliott Gould and Waj Ali discussing Bloody Mabel with host Ali Stroker on One Killer Question: The Only Murders In The Building aftershow.
A memorial for Bunny provides an opportunity for our trio to question their neighbors, while they also try to get rid of a very implicating piece of evidence. One of Bunny’s relatives makes an appearance and if you thought Bunny was a force, get ready…
A new celebrity resident of the Arconia. A new suspect! Michael Cyril Creighton and Da’Vine Joy Randolph join host Ali Stroker to ask: is Amy Schumer guilty? or totally guilty? on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building after show.
A foul-mouthed parrot becomes a critical window into Bunny Folger’s last day on Earth. Some of the individuals with whom Bunny crossed paths will surprise both you and our trio… Along the way, a reveal deepens our trio's need to solve Bunny’s case.
Tim Kono and Bunny kinda get the short end of the stick, huh? Well, not anymore! Join Ali Stroker with Julian Cihi (Tim Kono) and Jayne Houdyshell (Bunny) to hear the victims in Only Murders In The Building get the last word.
Charles, Oliver and Mabel welcome an unexpected young visitor who reveals hidden secrets about the inner workings of the Arconia. We also discover Charles once recorded a hit single that was huge in Germany.
Dads. They’re really a thing this season, huh? One Killer Question tackles the perils of paternity with host Ali Stroker, Ryan Broussard (Will) and superfan Elliott Gould in the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
Mabel hosts a party for an eclectic art crowd which also serves a double purpose for smoking out a liar in the trio’s midst.
The game’s afoot and it’s time to ask: who do we trust? Host Ali Stroker is joined by Dan Oreskes (Marv) and superfans Hayley Law and Waj Ali on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
Charles, Oliver and Mabel collide with their podcasting mentor-turned-competitor, Cinda Canning. Subsequently, a key clue requires the trio to orchestrate a classic stakeout — Brazzos-style. New York has never been more glittering.
Charles, Mabel and Oliver may be good sleuths. But their personal lives are a mess. Host Ali Stroker talks with Chris Redd and Melissa Rivers to dig into some poor life choices on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
Mabel’s incident on the subway leads her to gain help from an unlikely ally. Their journey takes them to a legendary amusement park which turns out to be full of terror — while amusements and evidence reside back in the Arconia with Charles and Oliver.
What if the man who killed your best friend saves your life… and maybe isn’t such a bad guy? Host Ali Stroker, James Caverly (Theo) and Ryan Broussard (Will) dig into all things Theo on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
A blackout throws the city into chaos. As the trio races to save a loved one from the killer, other Arconia residents begin to explore unexpected connections in the midst of darkness — all enhanced by Gut Milk and a yodel or two.
The power’s out and a killer is on the loose. Which Arconia resident do you turn to? Host Ali Stroker chats blackout buddies with Melissa Rivers and Ricky Dillon on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
Closing in on the killer, Mabel takes her investigative talents into the ring. Oliver and Charles duke it out over a birdcage only to end up confronting their deepest paternal struggles.
The case is heading to a close (we think?). But even if the killer is found, are our leads gonna be OK? Join host Ali Stroker and superfans Waj Ali and Hayley Law in One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
One question remains: Who did it??? Oh, who are we kidding — there’s a few more questions raised, too.
The killer’s identity is no longer a question. But we’ve still got a big one left to answer. Join host Ali Stroker, Jayne Houdyshell (Bunny) and Adina Verson (Poppy) on the S2 finale of One Killer Question, the only Murders in the Building aftershow.
Curtain up on Season 3! And Leading Man down! After Ben Glenroy’s collapse on stage, Charles, Oliver & Mabel piece together the show’s first days with a suspicious cast & crew to determine if foul play was involved. Spoiler alert…
We share our take on Ben Glenroy with host Michael Cyril Creighton, Jackie Hoffman (Uma) and Allison Guinn (KT) on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
Mable, Oliver & Charles attend Ben's lavish memorial full of fans and those with more dubious motives. As the actor's sudden death is mourned, Oliver works to revive his shaky Broadway show.
Who needs a job when you have a murder podcast? We explore Mabel’s life choices on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow with host Michael Cyril Creighton and guests David DeLouise and Drew Afualo.
Oliver races to bring new life to his show as Mabel's investigation into the actual murder collides with a surprising ally. Charles bonds with the cast, and Loretta proves her voice is invaluable.
Mabel made a new friend. Does Tobert spell trouble? Join host Michael Cyril Creighon, Jason Veasey (Jonathon) and Don Darryl Rivera (Bobo) on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
Charles's stage fright reaches unimaginable heights, involving a break from reality and multiple baby dolls. Mabel is confronted by a mysterious individual from her past with a pivotal proposal.
What the heck happened in the white room. And why are pants involved? Andrea Martin (Joy) and Kara Wang join host Michael Cyril Creighton to explore the mysteries of Charles' psyche in One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
Date night! New York proves itself both a jewel box and a fish tank of romance as Charles, Mabel & Oliver take their relationships to the next stage. And dating can reveal many hidden secrets, too...
Dating is tricky when your real passion is murder. We break down the trio’s love lives with Jay Manuel, Sophia Culpo, Jason Veasey (Jonathan) and host Michael Cyril Creighton on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
All roads lead the trio back to the Goosebury Theater during a nerve-rattling thunderstorm. With Howard as their jittery guide, they track a legendary ghost who’s haunted the theater for generations. Boo.
Do you believe in ghosts? Because in this episode everyone’s haunted. Let’s get exorcising with host Michael Cyril Creighton, Allison Guinn (KT) and Don Darryl Rivera (Bobo) on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
Charles finds an unexpected source for a major clue. A Broadway icon comes knocking at Oliver’s door. And Mabel forms an alternate trio to pursue a lead that sheds light on Ben’s bro and CoBro history.
Theo keeps popping up in Mabel’s life. Is it a sign? James Caverly (Theo) shares his unbiased take with Ryan Broussard (Will), Kat McNamara and host Michael Cyril Creighton on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
On the day of the show’s most critical rehearsal, the pressure mounts. A familiar official returns to upend the case, Loretta’s complex past threatens to upend all else and Charles must finally sing his number without losing his marbles.
Oliver’s always been self-obsessed. But this season he’s been flat out selfish. Join Andrea Martin (Joy), Ryan Broussard (Will) and host Michael Cyril Creighton to discuss on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
The trio have amassed a plethora (oh yes, a plethora) of clues, suspects & theories but find no concrete answers about Ben’s murder. They devise a peculiar method of throwing themselves into the actual case to recreate the final moments of Ben’s life.
Ben didn’t make a great first impression. But was he such a bad guy? We reevaluate this season’s victim with Jeremy Shamos (Dickey), Kat McNamara, Kara Wang and host Michael Cyril Creighton on the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
Curtain call on Season 3! Charles, Mabel & Oliver race to entrap the killer on Opening Night. As the musical thrills its Broadway audience, the trio brave further twists & turns from behind, above and all around the stage.
This episode reveals … oh wait, spoiler alert! We dig into the climactic finale with host Michael Cyril Creighton, Jeremy Shamos (Dickie) and Wesley Taylor (Cliff) on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.
