Grieving for the life he's abandoned, Matt suffers a crisis of faith. Fisk makes a deal with the FBI that turns him into a target.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jim Dunn | Writer | ||
| Martin Chavez | Guest Star | Man | |
| Jonathan O'Reilly | Guest Star | Nelson Nephew | |
| Gavin Haag | Guest Star | EMT | |
| Chris Colombo | Guest Star | Mr. Kazemi | |
| Michael Mulheren | Guest Star | Edward Nelson | |
| Elisabeth Ness | Guest Star | Young Mother | |
| Andy Lucien | Guest Star | Agent Ramsey | |
| Skylar Gaertner | Guest Star | Young Matt | |
| DeShawn Harold Mitchell | Guest Star | Agent | |
| Antoni Corone | Guest Star | Police Commissioner Chris DiMolina | |
| John Francis McNamara | Guest Star | Uncle Timmy | |
| James Foster Jr. | Guest Star | Old Man | |
| Don Castro | Guest Star | Agent Arinori | |
| Matthew McCurdy | Guest Star | Agent Wellers | |
| Patrick Cann | Guest Star | Agent | |
| Anabel Graetz | Guest Star | Old Albanian Woman | |
| Anne Carney | Guest Star | Aunt Jeanie | |
| Oliver Palmer | Guest Star | Delivery Guy | |
| Bill Winkler | Guest Star | Warden Riggle | |
| Matt DeAngelis | Guest Star | Jasper Evans | |
| Ari Blinder | Guest Star | Agent | |
| Ron Fehmiu | Guest Star | Albanian Mob Boss | |
| Arden Wolfe | Guest Star | Nelson Niece | |
| Jarrett Worley | Guest Star | Dry Cleaner / Kidnapper | |
| Dina Shihabi | Guest Star | Neda Kazemi | |
| Deirdre O'Connell | Guest Star | Anna Nelson | |
| Lukas Ettlin | Director |