The stranger turns out to be a bounty hunter named Saguru and delivers the kids to Lord Skycrusher. Tatsurion invokes his right to trial by combat and Ray and Allie are his opponents. Ray helps Tatsurion to use his Nature side to resist the mind control of Skycrusher's sword. Everyone manages to escape, while Saguru steals the FireSword and delivers it to the Choten for a slight look at Earth.
A series of strange robberies has been hitting the city. Ray, Allie, and Gabe discover that a thug named Heller is behind the robberies and has been using a gauntlet that he stole from Choten's men to control a Storm Patrol creature called Shaw K'Naw. During battle, Ray is temporary blinded and Master Jaha ends up having to train him to use his other senses to see while training with a Tarborg creature called Fumes.
Ray and his pals help Master Kimora probe some mysterious disappearances occurring in Mighty Shouter's tribe. Upon being caught by a claw emerging from the portal, Ray and Tatsurion discover that Choten and Aqua Seneschal are behind the abductions. Now Ray must find a way to free Tatsurion and the other captives of Choten without being spotted by Choten's minions.
Upon infiltrating Ray's house, Choten and Aqua Seneschal use a bunch of Memory Swarm to steal all of Ray's memories of Kaijudo. It's up to Allie & Gabe to get them back by traveling into the Water Civilization for the backup. Yet they soon get caught upon being accused of stealing a Water Civilization artifact and are brought before the Council of Logos.
Ray and Tatsurion duel in an arena competition for the Shield of Unity (an artifact that compels all other tribes to help whichever tribe possesses it) in order to help Gabe, Master Chavez, and Earthstomp Giant protect the Quillspike Tribe from the attacks by Midnight Crawler. While watching the battle, Allie notices that the Choten is in the audience and discovers he has created a plot to steal the Shield of Unity with Saguru posing as a Snow Faerie.
Ray and Tatsurion the Unchained must race Saguru and those in the finals to get to the Shield of Unity. When the Shield of Unity is stolen by Aqua Seneschal, Ray and Tatsurion the Unchained end up working with Saguru to recover the Shield of Unity. Meanwhile, Gabe, Master Chavez, and Gargle try to find a way to get out of Midnight Crawler and find a way to prevent it from eating more of the Quillspike Tribe's land.
Gabe follows his brothers to an abandoned amusement park at the old pier while tutoring them. Meanwhile, Fingers uses Impalicus (which Choten evolved from a Writhing Bone Ghoul) to target Gabe in order to find Ray. Now Gabe is put to the ultimate test to keep his brothers from getting attacked by Writhing Bone Ghoul before they see it.
Ray and Allie end up in a high stakes battle of wits against Alakshmi, Heller, and Saguru when the Choten makes another attempt at stealing the Helm of Ultimate Technology which has been hidden in the bank where Allie's father Arthur Underhill works. Gabe also alerts the other Masters in order to save the hostages and help to fight off the Choten's minions.
Following the incident at the bank, Master Jaha, Master Chavez, and Master Nadia leads an expedition to the Darkness Civilization to rescue Allie's father and endures multiple attacks. They soon learn from Master Jaha's contact Slyth that Arthur Underhill is in the clutches of Megaria, the Collector.
With Allie a prisoner of Megaria, Ray and the others formulate a plan to rescue Allie and return home with the Shield of Unity. Meanwhile, Alakshmi enters the Darkness Civilization in order to redeem herself to Choten and claim the Shield of Unity only for Megaria to have Razorkinder Puppet of Miasma Pit knock out Alakshmi. Now Megaria has Allie and Alakshmi fight each other to see who will become her pawn in a plot to expand her territory.
While trying to teach Carny a lesson following an incident at a parent-teacher conference, Ray and Tatsurion the Unchained find themselves stuck in the Fire Civilization with Carny and they must work together find their way back to Earth while evading Lord Skycusher's bounty hunters Blastforge Slavetrader and Burnclaw the Relentless. During this time, Ray ends up making a discovery about Carny's dad Alex where it turns out that Alex is one of Choten's benefactors and even learns more about Tatsurion the Unchained's father: Napalmian the Conquering.
Sasha, Channeler of Light returns to Earth upon being sent by the Light Civilization to study humans. While in a mortal disguise, Sasha is introduced to mean attitudes, cyber-bullies, and powerful emotions. All of this makes her question the humanity of humankind. At the same time, Alakshmi trains Carny to duel like her.
Master Nigel has sent the other Duel Masters and Acolytes to look for Choten's spell. Sasha, Channeler of Light sends a message to Gabe that the Light Civilization is under attack. The kids and Master Nigel travel to the Light Civilization to find Alakshmi (wielding the Sword of Fiery Cataclysm), Fingers (wielding the Cloak of Dark Illusion), and Heller (wielding the Shield of Unity) attempting to steal the final powerful artifact called the Heart of Light where the artifacts that Choten's minions wield act as a compass to the Heart of Light.
The Choten, Alakshmi, Fingers, Saguru, and Heller attack Ray’s apartment to get the fifth and final Creature Artifact. Making matters worse, The Choten activates a Summoning Inhibitor that prevents anyone or anything from crossing through the Veil within the targeted perimeter. During this time, Ray learns about his mother's past and what his father Ken was.
Now that the Choten has all five artifacts, he begins his plan to collapse the Veil and awaken the 5 Creature Kings. Ray, Gabe, and Allie escape from the Creature Realm and help the Duel Masters launch an attack on Choten's lair unaware that the Choten is prepared for their arrival by abducting Tatsurion the Unchained and the creature partners of the Duel Masters. Tatsurion the Unchained evolves into Evo Fury Tatsurion and grows wings. The Choten successfully awakens King Tritonus (the monarch of the Water Civilization).
As The Choten's plan appears to be falling into place upon awakening King Tritonus, Infernus the Immolater, Almighty Colossus, Queen Kaleema of the Infinite Dark, and Eternal Haven Angelic Liege, Ray, Gabe, Allie, and the Duel Masters must do everything in their power to save Earth from being changed forever.
Gargle visits Gabe's house and encounters Gabe's brothers. Elsewhere, Ray heads to the chemical plant after something odd occurs there.
Empress Megaria wants Allie to be her apprentice. Elsewhere, a truck carrying evolution serum vanishes.
Allie's loyalties to her friends are tested; Ray learns about non-violent resistance, and he uses his new knowledge when confronting Empress Megaria about Allie.
The kids are in peril at sea as they search for the San Campion Triangle; after August questions Saguru's compassion, the two of them engage in a duel.
Humans get replaced by look-alike holographs, so Ray seeks help from his uncle; Allie performs a spell and accidentally casts the temple into darkness.
Bob's mom gets abducted and taken to the Fire Realm, so Ray and Bob go on a rescue mission. However, the mission gets more complicated when Bob encounters adversaries from his past.
Ray receives a warning in a dream, so he and his pals cross the Veil and enter the Nature World. While there, Ray looks for a mystic who may possess the healing spell he seeks.
The kids and Master Isao unexpectedly find the Choten's ship, but making an undetected escape isn't feasible for them. Meanwhile, Alakshmi gets creative as she attempts to remove Sensei's armor.
Allie gets stuck to Alakshmi, so they join forces to combat Nigel as he tries to devise a Veil breach. Elsewhere, Ray and the Masters learn that the Choten is reaching out to the Darkness Realm Queen.
At the time when Carny is back in school, a bullied kid named Kevin steals one of Carny's tech-gauntlets and inadvertently opens the Veil which lets the Skeeter Swarmers into the school that take over everyone's bodies except Ray's body. Now he is the only one left to fight against this. Meanwhile, Queen Kalima starts to have her forces invade San Campion where the incidents with the Skeeter Swarmers gives Gregoria the opportunity to invade San Campion.
Ray has a family reunion with Master Isao. Meanwhile, Butterfly Effects prove harmful to San Campion.
The Water Realm causes damage to two other realms, so the kids seek help from four creatures who can join forces and ward off another attack.
Ray barters with the Choten, giving him a spell from the Water Mystic in exchange for a remedy for his father.
The Creature Monarchs must be gathered together in one locale in order to free Tritonus and halt the impending war in the Creature Realm.
The Adepts board the Choten's ship and figure out the plan for the missing evolution serum. Meanwhile, things fall into place for the Choten.
Ray gets to use coveted spell to halt the Choten's army, but it comes at a high personal cost.