Artemis (Mary Kate Wiles) and her twin brother, Paul (Steve Zaragoza), have their eyes on the coveted hosting position for the hit anthology podcast Wayward Guide for the Untrained Eye. But on the day of the big pitch to their boss Lesly (Sean Astin), they are derailed by an unexpected visit from a paranoid yokel (Darren Criss) claiming a massive conspiracy in his small mining town of Connor Creek.
Artemis and Paul begin to interview the town’s oddballs and eccentrics to gain some insight into the upcoming town council election. The discovery of a mysterious book leads the Schue-Horyn twins to suspect that there may be paranormal forces at play.
Artemis tries to find a connection between the town’s recent tragedy and a slick mining executive (Titus Makin). Meanwhile, Paul’s radical theory about werewolves creates a rift between him and his sister, leading to a dangerous investigation of his own.
Artemis offends candidate Truman Hensley (Cassie Silva) after making a brash decision at a town hall meeting. Paul’s suspicion that werewolves are behind the recent attacks grows stronger as he recovers from an eventful night.
Artemis makes a hair-raising discovery in the woods surrounding Connor Creek. Following the town council election, another gruesome attack causes pandemonium in the town.
With the town on high alert for werewolves, Artemis and Paul’s interviews take on a new tone. And panic turns to hysteria as this threat is put on full display at an emergency town council meeting.
Sheriff Madison is nominated to head-up a werewolf hunting task force as the town turns against the Schue-Horyns. Several locals make a startling confession as they attempt to form an alliance.
Artemis follows her primary lead to confront the mastermind behind the werewolf attacks, only to realize that she has missed a major detail in the case.
With the truth finally out in the open, Paul constructs a cockamamie plan to save the town with the help of an unexpected ally hidden in plain sight.
Answers are revealed as Connor Creek catches up to its feral history. Back at APN, Artemis and Paul deal with the repercussions of their story.
Podcast: An introduction to fraternal twin podcasting team Artemis and Paul Schue-Horyn and the American Podcasting Network (APN). Plus, a tease of the story of murder and werewolves yet to come on this season of The Wayward Guide for the Untrained Eye.
Podcast: After discussing the unlikely tip that led them to their story, Artemis and Paul pack their bags and hit the road. But upon arriving in the town of Connor Creek, the twins are met with tragedy.
Podcast: While interviewing a motley crew of locals about Miner Mole, a large mining corporation that has descended upon the town, Artemis and Paul learn more about Connor Creek’s hairy history.
Podcast: A deep dive into the town’s pro-mining contingent, Miner Mole, and unsavory local executive Silas Torsen. The danger intensifies, as the Schue-Horyn twins continue to poke around.
Podcast: Artemis and Paul consider the ramifications of their presence in Connor Creek, as they learn more about what’s at stake in the upcoming town council election.
Podcast: Paul takes to the polls to observe Connor Creek’s bizarre and convoluted election methods. Artemis has an “accident” which stirs up some dark rumors.
Podcast: Artemis and Paul’s story takes an unexpected turn. Confusion abounds as the locals react to murmurs of a werewolf on the loose.
Podcast: We learn more about Artemis and Paul’s good intentions, even as the townsfolk of Connor Creek turn against them.
Podcast: With the existence of a werewolf as their most substantial lead, the Schue-Horyn twins retrace their steps and revisit some of Paul’s outlandish theories.
The truth is revealed, as Artemis and Paul grapple with the meaning of their nightmarish experience.
Six months later, Artemis and Paul return to Connor Creek to catch up with the colorful townies and attend a special memorial event.
With the mystery of Connor Creek in the rearview, it's time to sit back, relax, and get ready to laugh! Enjoy this hearty collection of bloops, spoofs, yucks, and flubs from the production of Wayward Guide!!
