When David's train gets delayed he is forced to sprint through New York City to make it to his blind date on time. When he gets there however, he sits down across from the wrong Sarah. Or was she really the right one?
After losing Sarah F's number, David - with the help of his roommate, Z - is willing to do anything to find her
David goes to great lengths to see Sarah F again. Meanwhile Ben faces his first conflict between work and faith.
David and Sarah finally go on their first date. Jacobs explores foreign avenues for a love connection and Noa, Ben, and Z take up volunteering.
David and Z crash a wedding with the intention of wooing Sarah, but don't get the reception they expect. Jacobs and Noa face the pressures of being single at a Jewish wedding firsthand. Meanwhile, Ben begins to process some unfamiliar feelings, and Sarah learns about a family member's relationship issues.
One month after the season 1 finale, Jacobs and Ben deal with whatever happened at that wedding... Meanwhile, Z has a new friend, who may be interested in something more. Noa meets a smooth-talking guy, and may need to spend more time with him than she expected. Sarah's new job makes her consider her life choices.
It's a busy Sunday for the SBY gang. David and Sarah's day in the park gets tense when unexpected visitors tag along. Z and Kayla double-date with Noa and Jacob, but Z has ulterior motives. Meanwhile, Jacobs spends the day hunting down her new passion.
The gang goes on an outdoor adventure that takes an unexpected turn while Jacobs goes the extra mile to help a dater in need.