Matthew revisits the topic of how smooth he is with the women working behind the scenes of Criminal Minds. The self-proclaiming "lady's man" strikes up a conversation with Lily Kershaw, who played a guest role in the show and had several of her songs featured during episodes. Her father, Glenn, a prominent member of the production staff interrupts with a strongly-worded warning towards Matthew. Guest star James Van Der Beek is caught off-guard when approached by an "old friend" from "The Creek" that he somehow cannot remember. Matthew explains the discrepancy, reassuring his fans that Van Der Beek is indeed a close friend.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Matthew Gray Gubler | Actor | Himself |