Greg Miller hosts the most awesome moments in WrestleMania history. WWE Superstars and Legends debate and celebrate their favorite memories from The Showcase of the Immortals.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Theodore Long | Guest Star | Teddy Long | |
| Kazeem Famuyide | Guest Star | Kazeem Famuyide | |
| Dominik Gutiérrez | Guest Star | Dominik Mysterio | |
| Jeffrey Sciullo | Guest Star | Elias | |
| Theodore DiBiase Sr. | Guest Star | Ted DiBiase | |
| Andrew Galloway IV | Guest Star | Drew McIntyre | |
| Michael Hickenbottom | Guest Star | Shawn Michaels | |
| Charles Wright | Guest Star | The Godfather | |
| Austin Watson | Guest Star | Xavier Woods | |
| Marcel Barthel | Guest Star | Ludwig Kaiser | |
| Nicholas Nemeth | Guest Star | Dolph Ziggler | |
| Kenneth Crawford | Guest Star | Montez Ford | |
| Rami Sebei | Guest Star | Sami Zayn | |
| Mark LoMonaco | Guest Star | Bubba Ray Dudley | |
| Pamela Martinez | Guest Star | Bayley | |
| Steve Austin | Guest Star | "Stone Cold" Steve Austin | |
| Colby Lopez | Guest Star | Seth Rollins | |
| Matthew Clement | Guest Star | Tyler Breeze | |
| Mark Calaway | Guest Star | Undertaker | |
| Drew Gulak | Guest Star | Drew Gulak | |
| Adam Copeland | Guest Star | Edge | |
| Paul Heyman | Guest Star | Paul Heyman | |
| Glenn Jacobs | Guest Star | Kane | |
| Randal Keith Orton | Guest Star | Randy Orton | |
| Alexis Kaufman | Guest Star | Alexa Bliss | |
| Samuel Roberts | Guest Star | Sam Roberts | |
| Kevin Kesar | Guest Star | Karrion Kross | |
| Gary Gordon | Guest Star | Angelo Dawkins | |
| Kofi Sarkodie-Mensah | Guest Star | Kofi Kingston | |
| Tommaso Whitney | Guest Star | Tommaso Ciampa | |
| James Ross | Guest Star | Jim Ross | |
| Walter Hahn | Guest Star | Gunther | |
| Jeffrey Hardy | Guest Star | Jeff Hardy | |
| Mike 'The Miz' Mizanin | Guest Star | The Miz | |
| Terry Bollea | Guest Star | Hulk Hogan | |
| Luke Menzies | Guest Star | Ridge Holland | |
| James Hart | Guest Star | Jimmy Hart | |
| Cody Runnels | Guest Star | Cody Rhodes | |
| Kevin Scott Nash | Guest Star | Kevin Nash | |
| John Layfield | Guest Star | JBL | |
| Kimberly Benson | Guest Star | Piper Niven | |
| Candice LeRae Gargano | Guest Star | Candice LeRae | |
| Sean Waltman | Guest Star | X-Pac | |
| Cheree Crowley | Guest Star | Dakota Kai | |
| Ronald Simmons | Guest Star | Ron Simmons | |
| William Reso | Guest Star | Christian | |
| Nicola Glencross | Guest Star | Nikki Cross | |
| John Gargano | Guest Star | Johnny Gargano | |
| Sean Coulthard | Guest Star | Michael Cole | |
| Demi Bennett | Guest Star | Rhea Ripley | |
| Shelton Benjamin | Guest Star | Shelton Benjamin | |
| Bret Hart | Guest Star | Bret Hart | |
| Elizabeth Kociański-Copeland | Guest Star | Beth Phoenix | |
| Rebecca Quin | Guest Star | Becky Lynch | |
| Roderick Toombs | Guest Star | Roddy Piper (posthumous) | |
| Gionna Daddio | Guest Star | Liv Morgan |