Greg Miller presents the most awesome wrestling games of all time. WWE Superstars relive the nostalgia of battling their buddies back in the day and debate the classics.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sean Waltman | Guest Star | X-Pac | |
| Shelton Benjamin | Guest Star | Shelton Benjamin | |
| Ryan Satin | Guest Star | Ryan Satin | |
| Kevin Kesar | Guest Star | Karrion Kross | |
| Samuel Roberts | Guest Star | Sam Roberts | |
| Austin Watson | Guest Star | Xavier Woods | |
| Nicola Glencross | Guest Star | Nikki Cross | |
| Daniel Ryckert | Guest Star | Dan Ryckert | |
| Matthew Clement | Guest Star | Tyler Breeze | |
| Luis Martínez | Guest Star | Damian Priest | |
| Cody Runnels | Guest Star | Cody Rhodes | |
| Matthew Riddle | Guest Star | Matt Riddle | |
| Mark LoMonaco | Guest Star | Bubba Ray Dudley | |
| Gionna Daddio | Guest Star | Liv Morgan | |
| Stephanie Bell-Lee | Guest Star | Mia Yim | |
| Thea Trinidad-Büdgen | Guest Star | Zelina Vega | |
| Bret Hart | Guest Star | Bret Hart | |
| Nicholas Nemeth | Guest Star | Dolph Ziggler | |
| Elizabeth Kociański-Copeland | Guest Star | Beth Phoenix | |
| Shayna Baszler | Guest Star | Shayna Baszler | |
| Matt Camp | Guest Star | Matt Camp | |
| Kenneth Crawford | Guest Star | Montez Ford | |
| Allen Jones | Guest Star | AJ Styles | |
| Joseph Fatu | Guest Star | Solo Sikoa | |
| Drew Gulak | Guest Star | Drew Gulak | |
| Mike 'The Miz' Mizanin | Guest Star | The Miz | |
| Kimberly Benson | Guest Star | Doudrop | |
| Pamela Martinez | Guest Star | Bayley | |
| Thomas Pestock | Guest Star | Baron Corbin |