Host Greg Miller and the WWE Superstars debate and celebrate the most influential and awesome Superstar entrances in WWE history.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kurt Angle | Guest Star | Kurt Angle | |
| Sean Waltman | Guest Star | X-Pac | |
| Theodore DiBiase Sr. | Guest Star | Ted DiBiase | |
| Ronnie Killings | Guest Star | R-Truth | |
| Ronald Simmons | Guest Star | Ron Simmons | |
| Page Falkinburg Jr. | Guest Star | Diamond Dallas Page | |
| Solofa Fatu Jr. | Guest Star | Rikishi | |
| Eric Bugenhagen | Guest Star | Rick Boogs | |
| James Hart | Guest Star | Jimmy Hart | |
| Michael Foley | Guest Star | Mick Foley | |
| Stephen Farrelly | Guest Star | Sheamus | |
| Nora Benshoof-Greenwald | Guest Star | Molly Holly | |
| Samuel Roberts | Guest Star | Sam Roberts | |
| Charles Betts | Guest Star | Chad Gable | |
| William Goldberg | Guest Star | Goldberg | |
| Jeffrey Sciullo | Guest Star | Ezekiel | |
| Alexis Kaufman | Guest Star | Alexa Bliss | |
| Kenneth Crawford | Guest Star | Montez Ford | |
| Mark Calaway | Guest Star | Undertaker | |
| Elizabeth Kociański-Copeland | Guest Star | Beth Phoenix | |
| Austin White | Guest Star | Theory | |
| Dave Bautista | Guest Star | Batista | |
| Glenn Jacobs | Guest Star | Kane | |
| Steve Austin | Guest Star | Stone Cold Steve Austin | |
| Nikola Bogojević | Guest Star | Otis | |
| Demi Bennett | Guest Star | Rhea Ripley | |
| Sean Coulthard | Guest Star | Michael Cole | |
| Ashley Fliehr | Guest Star | Charlotte Flair | |
| Austin Watson | Guest Star | Xavier Woods | |
| Charles Wright | Guest Star | The Godfather | |
| Matthew Riddle | Guest Star | Riddle | |
| Macey Estrella-Kadlec | Guest Star | Lacey Evans | |
| Kimberly Benson | Guest Star | Doudrop | |
| Gionna Daddio | Guest Star | Liv Morgan | |
| Luis Martínez | Guest Star | Damian Priest | |
| Shane McMahon | Guest Star | Shane McMahon | |
| Andrew Galloway IV | Guest Star | Drew McIntyre | |
| Cody Runnels | Guest Star | Cody Rhodes | |
| Tommaso Whitney | Guest Star | Ciampa | |
| Eric Bischoff | Guest Star | Eric Bischoff | |
| Jerry Lawler | Guest Star | Jerry Lawler | |
| Maria Menounos | Guest Star | Maria Menounos | |
| Sidney Bateman | Guest Star | Reggie |