From the classics to the collectibles, Greg Miller unboxes the most awesome wrestling toys in WWE history; WWE Superstars recall the treasures that defined their childhood and fueled their imagination.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Matthew Polinsky | Guest Star | Corey Graves | |
| Brian Myers | Guest Star | Brian Myers | |
| Rebecca Quin | Guest Star | Becky Lynch | |
| Matthew Farrelly | Guest Star | Grayson Waller | |
| Luis Martínez | Guest Star | Damian Priest | |
| Bret Hart | Guest Star | Bret Hart | |
| Arda Ocal | Guest Star | Arda Ocal | |
| Thaddeus Bullard Sr. | Guest Star | Titus O'Neil | |
| Kevin Steen | Guest Star | Kevin Owens | |
| Mike 'The Miz' Mizanin | Guest Star | The Miz | |
| Natalya | Guest Star | Natalya | |
| Lawrence Pfohl | Guest Star | Lex Luger | |
| Sam Stoker | Guest Star | Kit Wilson | |
| Matthew Cardona | Guest Star | Matt Cardona | |
| Charles Wright | Guest Star | The Godfather | |
| Sean Waltman | Guest Star | X-Pac | |
| Dan Eardley | Guest Star | Pixel Dan | |
| Sarah Bridges-Rowe | Guest Star | Valhalla | |
| Samantha Johnson | Guest Star | Samantha Irvin | |
| Raymond Rowe Sr. | Guest Star | Erik | |
| Dominik Gutiérrez | Guest Star | Dominik Mysterio | |
| Michael Foley | Guest Star | Mick Foley | |
| Austin White | Guest Star | Austin Theory | |
| Matt Camp | Guest Star | Matt Camp | |
| Candice LeRae Gargano | Guest Star | Candice LeRae | |
| Ryan Pappolla | Guest Star | Ryan Pappolla | |
| Marcel Barthel | Guest Star | Ludwig Kaiser | |
| Colby Lopez | Guest Star | Seth Rollins | |
| Trevor Mann | Guest Star | Ricochet | |
| Lewis Howley | Guest Star | Elton Prince | |
| Austin Watson | Guest Star | Xavier Woods | |
| Demi Bennett | Guest Star | Rhea Ripley | |
| Kazeem Famuyide | Guest Star | Kazeem Famuyide | |
| Gionna Daddio | Guest Star | Liv Morgan | |
| Thea Trinidad-Büdgen | Guest Star | Zelina Vega | |
| Thomas Pestock | Guest Star | Baron Corbin | |
| Rami Sebei | Guest Star | Sami Zayn | |
| John Gargano | Guest Star | Johnny Gargano | |
| Gary Gordon | Guest Star | Angelo Dawkins | |
| Kenneth Crawford | Guest Star | Montez Ford | |
| Samuel Roberts | Guest Star | Sam Roberts | |
| Shayna Baszler | Guest Star | Shayna Baszler | |
| Christian Brigham | Guest Star | Carmelo Hayes | |
| Charles Betts | Guest Star | Chad Gable | |
| Tommaso Whitney | Guest Star | Tommaso Ciampa | |
| Sesugh Uhaa | Guest Star | Apollo Crews | |
| James Hart | Guest Star | Jimmy Hart |