Horace's tooth comes loose, giving him the perfect oppertunity to meet the toothfairy in person. But she never comes since Horace stays awake. Yaya explains that the toothfairy only appears when you're sleep. But Horace won't close his eyes until he meets the toothfairy. Wimzie starts a game of hide and seek, so she will put her plan into action to pose as the toothfairy to satisfy Horace. Horace falls asleep, but Gratziella accidentally trips and wakes him up. Horace gets wise, but is still shocked to find the toothfairy finally visited him when he was sleeping.