Game 1: Gus Mauch (signed in as ""Mr. X"" but the panel was not blindfolded) - ""Trainer for N.Y. Yankees"" (Alwyn Charles Mauch) Game 2: Jay Shore & Paul Shore (wife & husband team) - ""U.S. Mailmen"" (from Albuquerque, New Mexico) Game 3: Maria Fletcher (as Mystery Guest) - ""Miss America 1962"" (from Asheville, North Carolina) Game 4: Dave Marifield - ""Does Trapeze Act From Helicopter"" (from Summit, New Jersey)