Game 1: William C. Westmoreland & John Davidson - ""Superintendents: West Point & Annapolis"" aka General William Westmoreland & Admiral John Davidson Game 2: Nancy Pomroy - ""Lobster Fisherman"" Game 3: Zsa Zsa Gabor (as Mystery Guest #2) Game 4: Maureen Napier - ""Tour Guide on Sightseeing Boat (New York City)""