Game 1: Grace Lake - ""Window Washer"" (from Byram Township, Sussex County, New Jersey) Game 2: Robert Sullivan - ""Grows Christmas Trees"" (in Sheerland Forest; from Berks County, Reading, Pennsylvania) Game 3: Richard Rodgers & Oscar Hammerstein II (as Mystery Guest Duo) Game 4: James Wilfong - ""Shoes Horses"" (from Ann Arbor, Michigan)