Game 1: John Perona (as Mystery Guest #1 and the panel was blindfolded) - ""Owner of New York's El Morocco Nightclub"" (his famed restaurant is on East 54th Street in Manhattan, NY) Game 2: A Scotsman who makes kilts (He is dressed in a kilt) Game 3: Greer Garson (as Mystery Guest) Per Gil Fates' handwritten logs, there was not enough time for the next scheduled contestant, a person who was a probation officer.