Game 1: Donald Farrell (signed in as ""Mr. X"" but the panel was not blindfolded) - ""Airman First Class U.S.A.F."" (See notes below) Game 2: Mayte Morris - ""Bartender"" (at the Rock City Hotel; from Little Valley, New York) Game 3: Judy Holliday (as Mystery Guest #2) Game 4: Arthur Glowka - ""Dives for Diamonds in Brazilian Rivers"" (from Scarsdale, New York)