Game 1: June Taylor & the June Taylor Dancers (as Mystery Guest Group and the panel was blindfolded) - ""June Taylor Dancers of Jackie Gleason Show"" (there were 32 members of the dancing group on stage surrounding John Daly, described as 16 dancers and 16 glee girls) Game 2: Captain Al Beale - ""Suez Canal Pilot"" (salaried; from College Park, MD) Game 3: William Holden (as Mystery Guest #2) He signed in as Bill Holden. Game 4: Earl Knauer - ""Makes Moth Balls"" (salaried; originally from Walnut Grove, PA; currently from Davidsville, PA)