Game 1: Major A. N. Richie - ""Buckingham Palace Guard"" (salaried; the panel was blindfolded since he was in full uniform complete with his tall bear hat; he is a member of the Scots Guards Guard Order; from London, England) Game 2: Robert DeNoyelles - ""Sells Candy For Dogs"" (salaried; from New York, NY) Game 3: Joe Di Maggio (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Mrs. Celia Plaut - ""Hatcheck Girl"" (salaried; elderly; John states that she works at - what sounded like - ""The Cafe Glenshee"" in NYC; she had been mentioned in Dorothy's newspaper column this week, but no details were given as to why Dorothy didn't recognize her name; from New York, NY)