Game 1: Miss Mildred Gilmore - ""Private Eye"" (self-employed; from Los Angeles, CA) Game 2: Miss Nancy Vrana - ""Bartender"" (salaried; from Chestertown, NY) Game 3: Ann Sothern (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: James Denebaum - ""Test Driver of Army Trucks"" (salaried; John said he actually drives tanks; from Schenectady, NY)
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ann Sothern | Guest Star |