Game 1: Mrs. Leila Bulgrin - ""Federal Prosecuting Attorney"" (salaried; John said she was from Los Angeles, California, and she later clarified that she is actually from Tujunga, CA) Game 2: Ted Pfiffer - ""Makes Sea-Sick Pills"" (salaried; from Bloomfield, New Jersey) Game 3: Duke Ellington (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Joseph Wagner - ""Tea Bag Inspector"" (salaried; from Weehawken, New Jersey)
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Duke Ellington | Guest Star |