Game 1: Ron Brownell - ""Bank President"" (from Mount Kisco, NY) Game 2: Bob Montana - ""Elephant Keeper"" (at a zoo; from Yonkers, NY) Game 3: William O'Dwyer (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Kurt Prinz - ""Good Humor Ice Cream Vendor"" (from Long Island, NY)
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| William O'Dwyer | Guest Star |