Nightmare on Elm Street REBOOT Who Should Play Freddy Krueger (Nightmare on Elm Street) UPDATE! They are actually rebooting this! So its a possibility! So we bring this vid back to life! We re-cast the great Freddy Krueger and talk about who should play Freddy in the next Nightmare on Elm Street movie if its ever made and it we cant have Robert Englund! Who should play Freddy Krueger? Comment Below!