Mitch and Tracy struggle with what to tell Sadie when her favorite chicken at school dies. Mitch's sister brings her psychic boyfriend to dinner. Angie and Russell argue about religion.
When a gay car salesman assumes Mitch and Russell are a couple, Mitch plays it up to get a better deal on a vehicle. Tracy convinces Angie to try to use another woman's gym membership.
Angie accidentally hires one of Russell's exes as an interior decorator. Mitch explains guy code to Tracy.
Mitch And Angie search for common ground on an unexpected lunch date. Russel and Tracy sharing office space.
When new neighbors move in across the street, Mitch is determined to make a good impression but when their barking dog keeps Trace and Sadie awake all night, Mitch has to find a way to keep the peace.
Mitch accuses a restaurant owner of discrimination, then realizes he might be mistake. Tracy thinks her daughter is involved in a bullying incident at school.
Russell is upset when Derek and Charlene ask Mitch to officiate their wedding rather than him. Gossip threatens to derail the wedding.