Contestants: Gene Beene (The Human Bomb), Alfred Siefker (A young paleontologist who discovered a prehistoric animal capable of flight) , Al Summers (an umpire who runs an umpire school) Panel: Kitty Carlisle, Dina Merrill, Tom Poston, Don Ameche
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dina Merrill | Guest Star | ||
| Gene Beene | Guest Star | ||
| Tom Poston | Guest Star | ||
| Alfred Siefker | Guest Star | ||
| Don Ameche | Guest Star | ||
| Al Summers | Guest Star | ||
| Kitty Carlisle | Guest Star |