On August 21 and 23 in 2012, Holmes recorded three episodes for TBS entitled "The Midnight Show with Pete Holmes". His guests on the unaired pilots included Nick Offerman, Joel McHale, T.J. Miller and Bill Burr.
Studio guest Jim Jefferies; Pete talks pick-up lines with James Harden and shoots hoops at his Basketball Camp.
Studio guest Chelsea Peretti.
Studio guest Ike Barinholtz.
Studio guest Anthony Jeselnik; Pete goes to the BET Hip Hop Awards.
Studio guests Casey Wilson & June Diane Raphael; Pete skates with Olympic hopefuls Gracie Gold & Max Aaron.
Studio guest Deepak Chopra.
Studio guest Eric André.
Studio guest Rob Corddry.
Studio guest Rory Scovel; Rachel Maddow shows Pete how to make it as a host from her office in NYC.
Studio guest Whitney Cummings; Pete practices with US Olympic freeskiier Devin Logan.
Studio guest Jeff Garlin.
Studio guest Nick Kroll; 13-year-old street artist Skyler Grey.
Studio guest Doug Benson.
Studio guest Adam Pally.