While searching for Candied Island, K'nuckles and Flapjack find an island with a mechanical genie. The genie tricks Flapjack and K'nuckles into thinking it knows where Candied Island is, and K'nuckles bets their lives on a game where he must find a ball under one of three cups. K'nuckles loses, and he and Flapjack become the genie's butlers forever. After making them do pointless tasks, K'nuckles is infuriated with the genie and tries to destroy it. Flapjack and K'nuckles then discover that the mechanical genie was actually a game controlled by a giant baby that keeps them on the island as his 'toys'. The island is then shown to be the ball under the mechanical genie's cups, who is back at Stormalong. Flapjack then pulls the genie's electric cord from an outlet.