The team is amazed when an evolving theory accurately identifies two man-made anomalies that they believe may be landmarks created to pinpoint the Money Pit.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joe Lessard | Writer | ||
| Jason Broome | Producer | Supervising Producer | |
| John Wells | Producer | ||
| Edward Peill | Producer | for Tell Tale International Inc. | |
| Christopher 'Chris' Morford | Guest Star | Self - Theorist | |
| Laird Niven | Guest Star | Self - Archaeologist | |
| David Irving | Guest Star | Self - General Manager, Irving Equipment Ltd. | |
| Tom Nolan | Guest Star | Self - Landowner | |
| Aaron Taylor | Guest Star | Self - Archaeologist | |
| Gary Drayton | Guest Star | Self - Metal Detection Expert | |
| Ian Spooner | Guest Star | Self - Geoscientist | |
| David MacInnes | Guest Star | Self - Archaeologist | |
| Steve Guptill | Guest Star | Self - Surveyor | |
| Liz Michels | Guest Star | Self - Archaeologist | |
| Corjan Mol | Guest Star | Self - Theorist | |
| Doug Crowell | Guest Star | Self - Oak Island Historian | |
| Alan Kostrzewa | Executive Producer | for Oak Island Tours Inc. | |
| Rick Lagina | Executive Producer | for Oak Island Tours Inc. | |
| Kim Egan | Executive Producer | ||
| Craig Tester | Executive Producer | for Oak Island Tours Inc. | |
| David Comtois | Executive Producer | ||
| Jon A. Levy | Executive Producer | ||
| Kevin Burns | Executive Producer | ||
| Ismael Soto | Executive Producer | Co-Executive Producer | |
| Marty Lagina | Executive Producer | for Oak Island Tours Inc. | |
| Joe Lessard | Executive Producer | ||
| Brian Bowers | Executive Producer | Co-Executive Producer |