James discusses a plan that has dire consequences and fears his legacy will be that of a killer. Meanwhile, Sister Carmel wants to hear God again.
Allen completes his task but realizes he made the wrong deal, Willem meets his dream girl, and Mrs. Tyler has doubts about finishing what she started.
Jenny asks to recruit an accomplice. Meanwhile, Melody grows closer to Ron but is concerned about his behavior, and Willem's paranoia grows.
The kidnapper's identity is revealed, and James tracks him down. Later, Melody goes to the police after she uncovers disturbing information.
Allen comes to terms with his wrongdoing but fears for his son's safety, Richard makes a new deal, and Gerald asks for the unthinkable.
The Man who sits at the booth at the end returns, but this time it’s a new diner in a new city with new and unexpected clients.
The Man’s clients contemplate the implications of their desires and the Man comes face to face with a person from his past.
Clients grow restless as they try to perform their tasks and The Man himself starts to wonder about human nature.
The Man’s clients strive to continue on, even if consequences might be dire. The Man decides to get involved.
The fates of the clients collide. The Man learns that his actions may have made a difference…and also may have opened a door.
