In this episode, Andy hosts the Neighborhood Awards, the gang plays Duck, Duck, Goose and Herbie gets All-American Rejected.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The All-American Rejects | Guest Star | ||
| Tyson Ritter | Guest Star | ||
| Nick Wheeler | Guest Star | ||
| Mike Kennerty | Guest Star | ||
| Chris Gaylor | Guest Star |