Sara tells Casey that she was expecting more of a crowd, so he told her that he threw everyone out so that they could have some privacy. Sara spilled her wine on Casey, and then the hors d'oeuvres that Casey was heating up burned. When Casey went upstairs to change into a dry shirt, Sara found a romance novel, and had a fantasy about Casey sweeping her off her feet. When he heard Meg admit that she had similar problems with Derek to the ones that Maria had with him, Ben stopped her from telling any more and proved that Maria hadn't remembered anything. Meg got angry at Maria for lying, but Maria said that she'd lie again, if it meant that she could find out about that night.