While Annie is doing her best to stop Caitlin from telling Cole the truth, Sean is trying to convince Caitlin to tell everyone the truth. While on confession, Olivia refuses to listen to Antonio's advice to tell Caitlin the truth about Cole. Ben confesses to Tim about the murders, he say that he would have killed everyone if Tim hadn't shown up. Ricardo asks Tim to dig up some info about Ben, so he could re-open the Terror Island case.