Oranjestad, Aruba. Solved, October 2023. In May 2005, 18-year-old Natalee Holloway takes a Spring Break trip to Aruba with her girlfriends to celebrate their last year of high-school. During a night of fun and partying at a beach bar, Natalee and her friends meet a few young men who match the girls' spirit of fun. As the night wears-on, the group splits-up. Some head back the hotel, while others stay out for more partying. When Natalie's friends wake-up in their hotel the next morning, Natalie's not there. Local authorities can't find her either. So, Natalee's family calls in the FBI. After five years of rumors and false leads, investigators finally piece together the grim truth of what happened to Natalie that night: she'd been murdered and the crime covered-up. In the end, the FBI brings her killer to justice.