The Show Offs go contemporary with this version of a “Broadway Today” musical. Hailey and Lisa improvise a dynamite duet called “Get Off My Lawn!” which inspires the full musical named by the audience as, “The Grass is Always Greener.” The cast launches into a long history between the two former high school best friends. The rivalry heats back up when Lisa moves back into the neighborhood right next to her arch nemesis, Hailey. To fuel the fire, their respective husbands add to the drama as they defend their spouses' honor with a Zumba dance off. The only hope to restore peace comes from Ivan, the Russian lawn expert, and Sarah, the mysterious town council woman looking for love.
In this episode, the Show Offs perform a golden age musical set in the '50s in middle America. Maclain and Suazo are from the big city, but have come to the countryside to get away from it all and maybe find a gal. They luck out at a local dance by finding two small-town girls, but they have to pull out all the stops to win their love.
In this episode the Show Offs improvise a spaghetti western in Knownstown, Texas. An evil cattle baron vows to take over the town but one man and one woman stand in his way. Saddle up with the Show Offs as they showdown at sundown in this episode. There's no telling what Casey will make these cowboys come up with.
The Show Offs take on the fantasy genre with special guest, Kelly Stables (Superstore, The Exes). Jake is an evil wizard that has released a terrible dragon to terrorize the land. If that wasn't enough the audience made it a platypus dragon, as per Casey's interjection, so it can go on both land and sea. Kelly is a beautiful damsel who thinks to drain the moat in order to limit the creature's powers but of course she needs help from Will, the barbarian warrior. Everything seems to go well until someone reveals themself to be a traitor in the evil wizard's hands. The cast and Casey make the audience's wildest dreams come true. Watch as a special guest from the audience is chosen to play a key role in the finale.
The Show Offs do an improvised rock opera with the help of celebrity guest, Joey Fatone (N'SYNC). Joey shows off his pipes and rock star roots as he teams up with the Show Offs for some musical magic. In a tale as old as time, a young group of ice-dancing rock stars are about to make it big until Joey finds out he needs a kidney transplant. His fellow bandmate, Maclain agrees to help save his friend by donating his own. The operation is a success and so is their group until a big hollywood producer offers to take Joey solo for more money than he can imagine. He leaves his buddies behind but he can't forget their memory, especially in the hair-raising improvised number, “Joey's Gone Home.”
New York City is bustling with Christmas preparations, but not everyone is joyful. Barnaby is worried about how to provide for his large family, especially after an impulsive shopping spree leads to a Christmas beatdown. Meanwhile, Mr. Tree, a greedy and miserable man refuses to find any joy in the holiday, even at the insistence of his good natured daughter. That is, until he meets an elf who shares the gift of mistletoe and changes his outlook on life, leading him to help Barnaby with his troubles.
It's the happiest day of their lives for Greg and his new bride as they celebrate their wedding with a dessert pudding bar. But not everyone is having a great time: best man Timmy is cynical and alone, cousin of the bride Caroline is self-conscious and timid, and the bride's jilted ex-boyfriend and his unemployed mother decide to crash the wedding.
As this fairy tale goes, when the magical rose blossoms the forest will be changed forever as the reigning elf king dies and his son transforms from human to elf and becomes the new ruler. But the prince, having fallen in love with a human, is desperate to stop the rose from blooming and separating him from his true love.
Centaurs and humans alike reside together in a magical forest. But lo! Another eclipse is upon them, and it brings destruction on all. Join the Show Offs and guest stars Aliza Pearl and Jake Suazo on this boisterous improv journey to stop the eclipse from happening. Will this fairy tale have a happily ever after?