On a Friday night in 2009, mother-of-two Nancy Moyer vanished from her home in the small town of Tenino, Washington. In the decade since Nancy went missing, police have investigated numerous credible leads. Could a gruesome murder committed not far from Nancy’s home in 2010 be connected to her disappearance? In July 2019, a man allegedly confessed to Nancy’s murder but then recanted; is he really guilty or innocent? Stephanie Bauer visits Tenino to meet Nancy’s family and try to find answers in this most mysterious case.