In the first episode, Rinder guides us through the case of a bipolar Sunday school teacher Melissa Huckaby, who was accused of the sexual assault and murder of Sandra Cantu.
The second episode examines the notorious 'antifreeze murders' that took place in 2012. Diane and Rachel Staudte murdered two members of their family and attempted to kill a third before police got involved.
In the third episode, Rinder examines the case of double-murderer Cheyanne Jessie. On 1st August 2015, police received a call from Cheyanne Jessie in which she claimed her father Mark Weekly, and daughter Meredith were missing. But police would soon find out that this was not just a missing persons case and that the pair had been murdered a couple of weeks prior.
In the fourth episode, Rinder examines the murder of Cassandra Valentin by her fiancé Marvin Williams. Williams and Valentin had begun dating in 2004 but their relationship quickly became violent, and Valentin filed a number of domestic violence injunctions against Williams over the years.
In the fifth episode, Lee Rodarte Jnr, a chef at The Bonefish Grill in Jacksonville, Florida, murdered his colleague and ex-lover Savannah Gold.
Robert Rinder and a host of experts examine the interrogation tapes linked to Jayden Parkinson's murder, a case which garnered national media attention
