Matt Martin has spent countless hours and thousands of dollars renovating his fixer-upper home. Only one thing stands in the way of its completion, the unsightly old roof. Not only is the roof an off-center eyesore, it is also full of leaks that threaten to ruin the rest of the work he has completed inside. That's why Matt enlists the help of his big brother Casey and together they begin taking the old roof down piece by piece. They start off strong, but when the brothers begin to encounter unforeseen obstacles like unstable, rotted wood and damaged tarpaper, they are faced with the biggest obstacle of all, each other.