When Christmas Eve rolls around, Phil tells the story of when his family first came to Pickford and how he met Keely. Lloyd also decides to tell the story of how they got the house.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Julie Sherman Wolfe | Writer | ||
| J.P. Manoux | Guest Star | ||
| Geoff Brown | Guest Star | ||
| Fred Savage | Director |