A Lie Worth Fighting For

Lily findet im Keller von Doktor Darwell Tonbänder, auf denen Robert den Mord an Meredith Weller gesteht. Zusammen mit Henry beschließt sie, die Bänder zu stehlen. Währenddessen hat Robert ganz andere Probleme, denn Tom hatte während eines Streits mit ihm einen tödlichen Unfall. Um den Tod zu vertuschen, verscharren Robert und Nate die Leiche im Wald. Auch bei Will läuft einiges schief, denn er erfährt von Catherines Affäre mit dem neuen Pfarrer und droht ihr mit Scheidung ...

Robert attacks Henry and puts him in a headlock, but Henry bites Robert's arm and is able to fight him off and escape. He sneaks over to the McAllister house and tells Lily what happened. Robert comes over at the same time, and commiserates with Catherine, who tells him about the collapse of her marriage. They agree that they must kill Henry to protect the family's secrets. Henry tells Tom that Robert attacked him, but asks him to go to work and act as though nothing has happened while he and Lily retrieve the evidence. Charlie orders Lily to forget about the tapes. He knows that revealing the truth would destroy both of their families, and will have no part in it. He insists that they shouldn't care about exacting justice for Meredith Weller's death, because it happened long ago and they didn't know her. Lily sneaks out of class to break into the Darwell house with Henry. She is reluctant, but Henry reminds her that he will be on the run for the rest of his life unless her fa