After the contestant selection is over, everyone congregates by the pool to discuss the outcome of Keith being the next guest. Toni admits that she accidentally voted for a different guy than Kristin and Amy wanted. Is the wrong guy is coming to Paradise? Alex makes fun of them for picking a male model, and Toni leaves abruptly. Zack becomes angry at Toni's actions. The other girls tell him to shut up. Kristin finds Toni back at the room and consoles her. Toni feels like she disappointed both her and Amy. Kristin was only disappointed in the way Toni took off. When Toni confesses that she wants to go home, Kristin says not to tell anyone. Zack and Amy leave the pool because he ""can't take it up there."" He calls Toni an actress and a faker. Amy defends her, saying Toni's always been this way. Zack then moves on to criticizing Amy. He is pissed that Amy always wants him to be the one to initiate conversation as well as sexual activity. She never shows how she's attracted to him. Zack bri