No. 20: Phillies at Cubs, May 17, 1979. The Phillies defeated the Cubs by a score of 23–22.
No. 19: Giants at Marlins, October 4, 2003
No. 18: Phillies at Astros, October 12, 1980
No. 17: Yankees at Red Sox, October 17, 2004. The Yankee collapse in the 2004 ALCS begins.
No. 16: Tigers at Twins, October 6, 2009
No. 15: Yankees at Mariners, October 8, 1995
No. 14: Phillies at Blue Jays, October 23, 1993
No. 13: Indians at Marlins, October 26, 1997
No. 12: Diamondbacks at Yankees, October 31, 2001
No. 11: Yankees at Red Sox, October 2, 1978
No. 10: Athletics at Dodgers, October 15, 1988
No. 9: Yankees at Diamondbacks, November 4, 2001
No. 8: Red Sox at Angels, October 12, 1986
No. 7: Marlins at Cubs, October 14, 2003: "The Bartman Game."
No. 6: Red Sox at Yankees, October 16, 2003: Boone homers off Wakefield.
No. 5: Mets at Astros, October 15, 1986
No. 4: Pirates at Braves, October 14, 1992
The 2nd best game in MLB history based on votes from an expert panel and MLB Network viewers.
No. 1: Reds at Red Sox, October 21, 1975