After Donna and Rick got married, they were ready to find a home to start a family in. Three kids later, they've outgrown that perfect home that they started out in. The baby has no bedroom, the entry is a disaster, and the kitchen has seen better days. Donna is done with this place and wants to move, but Rick thinks their house just needs a little polishing to get back to its original luster. It's game on for Designer Jillian and Realtor Todd. Jillian has to turn an outdated mess into a home run, while Todd has to find a brand new place that covers all the bases. Can this diamond in the rough turn into a real gem or is it time for Donna and Rick to dig up a new treasure? Can they love their home again or will they list it?