The episode begins in a flashback with Louie filming the pilot for a sitcom. After complaining about the unrealistic dialogue and use of Bob Saget as the next door neighbor, Louie is shown arriving home to an unseen and presumably upset wife and their newborn baby Lilly. The episode then jumps to Lilly's tenth birthday. Louie sets out to obtain Lady GaGa concert tickets as a birthday present for his daughter, but doing so means he has to approach Dane Cook, a very successful comedian who is upset by accusations he has stolen material from Louie.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Louis C.K. | Writer | ||
| Jim Norton | Guest Star | ||
| Dane Cook | Guest Star | ||
| Bob Saget | Guest Star | ||
| Louis C.K. | Director |