Holly (Megan Hilty) returns home for Christmas to learn that her family’s department store is on the brink of foreclosure. To try and keep the business going, Holly fills in as Santa’s Helper. It’s there she meets Nick (Noah Mills), who has been hired to play Santa at the store. Their charisma draws in big crowds—until Nick suddenly disappears. With only a misplaced black boot as a clue, Holly begins her search to hopefully find him in time for Christmas Day.