Every year, Isabelle (Tatyana Ali) and her high school sweetheart, Mike (Cornelius Smith Jr.), impressed the town with their sweet Christmas duet at the annual Christmas Eve Pageant. But Isabelle left for New York after graduation and left him behind. Now, years later, Isabelle returns home to write the music for the Pageant and is shocked to learn Mike is the one directing the show. Will the former couple be able to put their differences aside for another festive duet? Loretta Devine, Valerie Pettiford, Obba Babatunde, Keshia Knight Pulliam and Tempestt Bledsoe also star.