After Faith (Hilarie Burton-Morgan) follows a holiday tradition in her town to pit a wish in a box, she thinks her dreams come true when she meets a handsome man named Andrew (Cristian de la Fuente) the next day. However, as her relationship continues, she begins to wonder if he’s really the right man for her—or if she should have been looking towards her best friend, Wyatt (Tyler Hilton) instead. Megan Park and Pam Grier also star.