At a family funeral, Lulu invents a Jewish boyfriend to appease her parents before sneaking out to hook up with her very real non-Jewish boyfriend Ollie.
Lulu's attempt to come clean to her brother Leo only results in her being reminded again of just how untenable her situation really is. She suggests a way of solving both of their problems but Leo wants nothing to do with her unhinged proposal.
Struggling to deal with her breakup, Lulu reconnects with her best friend Sina. Meanwhile, Ollie investigates what it would take to get Lulu back.
Lulu forges ahead with her foolhardy plans, bringing her whole family along for the ride, all while trying desperately to put Ollie out of her mind.
Not speaking to her family or the man she is living with is diminishing Lulu's pregnancy glow. But when a family crisis occurs, Lulu and Ollie put aside their argument and finally talk about what they really want.
Lulu and Ollie move in with friends, but Lulu discovers it’s not as easy as she thought to return to her pre-birth self. She and Ollie are surprised by the new Rabbi’s plans for them.
Lulu and Ollie undertake a fast-tracked religious learning path with their new Rabbi, which creates issues in the home when they attempt to ‘Jew-over’ the flat.
Lulu and Ollie’s differing experiences of the conversion process come to a head when they are forced to host a meal for Rabbi Wolf.
Lulu’s mounting doubts and denial come to a head when it matters most, leaving Ollie alone at the altar of his circumcision.
The divided family are forced to attend Hershey’s party. Lulu must confront her avoidance of the baby she gave away - but is it too late for her and Ollie?