Teresa, Jared, and Adam have to help intercity orphans paint a mural for a school project and struggle with the angry leader who obviously has problems. The church confronts Aaron about the past summer—and squeal on Chloe, who was the mysterious guest and coaxes Aaron about their reality, but he refuses to listen. Sarah goes looking for her next big break and starring role and wants Blayke to help her, but he doesn't feel right about it. Cicely's grandfather takes a turn for the worst and realizes that everyone is her friend when they show up at the hospital (even Aaron). Joshua tries to talk to Anna, but she fears the worst while Colby dodges Lily and the ever-present Bryce at the hotel.