As Christmastime approaches, Sarah toils with the idea of dropping out of the play after she loses Teresa for good and also isn't being talked to by Cicely, Korky and Coulier, but is unexpectedly talked out of it by Blayke, who tells her to forget them. Kalyopie helps out a struggling Billy in school after his new Christmas act at Belly's is a hit. Charlotte and Jared leave the church that Aaron, Anna, Gaby, Brody and Chastity go to after they show movies on abortion that she doesn't believe in, causing her to be shunned by the rest. Carl asks Gretchen out, and the date goes awry after his parents, brothers and sisters follow them on his ""first date"". Also, Colby and Lily have a crashed date after they ""run into"" Bryce.