Aspiring documentary filmmaker Mike Sylvan (Zach Pruett) forces himself into the life of aspiring actor Jordan Ross. Mike films Jordan's life, and they hold a party for the successful documentary that they haven't made yet. Mike discovers Jordan's disgusting eating habits, and tries to end his problem.
Mike spends the night at Jordan's house, whom Mike still doesn't know all that well. Mike just wants to get some sleep, but Jordan has other plans.
After a close call with a toilet, Jordan has Mike help him with some monologues for an upcoming play audition. However, the character that Jordan intends on auditioning for isn't quite the standard.
Jordan runs away from home after believing his house is haunted by ghosts, but things may not be as they seem.
Jordan has a run-in with the guy who stole his part in West Side Story, Ryan, who also happens to be Mike's nephew. Craziness ensues as Mike replaces Jordan with Ryan, and Jordan tries to survive on his own in Mike's garage.
Mike plans a fun evening of bowling for he and Jordan, but Jordan becomes obsessed with an arcade crane game.
Jordan leaves for the 'Glee' convention, leaving Mike alone at Jordan's house. Mike is told he can't touch Jordan's DVDs, but Mike can't resist, accidentally breaking one.
When Jordan isn't feeling so hot, Mike vows to take care of him. However, Jordan may not be able to handle Mike's overbearing care.
Jordan has a date with someone he and Mike dub 'Hot Girl'. Jordan finds her gross and off-putting, but Mike automatically falls in love.
Jordan's twin brother Gordon takes away Jordan for a film opportunity, leaving Mike all alone. Mike struggles to keep the documentary going by himself, and several shocking revelations are revealed.
Jordan tries to force Christmas spirit into Mike almost two months early, and when he rejects it, Jordan uses three spirits to show Mike the error of his ways.
Mike can't take the change of Jordan moving from upstairs to downstairs, and after finding out their beloved bowling alley is closed, Mike and Jordan try to find a place to call home.
Jordan, the self proclaimed 'Pool Master' helps Mike prepare for his upcoming pool tournament.
Mike leaves for a British convention, and Jordan is trapped inside Mike's house with his nemesis, Ryan Sylvan. They must overcome their differences to escape.
When Jordan begins down the depressing road of Mountain Dew addiction, Mike swears to help him get over it. The two party harder than they have ever partied before.
Jordan's Inception-like device that allows people to enter another persons dream transports Mike into a world where there are four clone Jordans, and Ryan Sylvan is kept in a cage and tortured.
Jordan and Mike go on a date with girls who are unimpressed by them. They vow to win them back by becoming more athletic. They try out several sports, leading up to a basketball showdown against two wannabe gangsters (Daniel Lawrence and Jake Kovacs), while being watched by a judgmental audience (Trent Scifres, Bryce Flory, and Justin Benjamin). (Ryan Cage also has a brief cameo).
Jordan steals Mike's opportunity to direct an anti-depressant pill commercial, and Mike enlists Ryan's help to sabotage the commercial, but it leads to Mike starring in it and Ryan being the cameraman.
While searching for ice cream, Jordan runs into Hot Girl (from season one, episode nine 'Hot Girl') and her boyfriend, Ben. Ben takes offense in Jordan calling her Hot Girl, and challenges him to a fight. Mike helps Jordan prepare for this fight.
Mike writes a play, and while practicing for it, he, Jordan and Ryan get trapped in Mike's garage. Shocking secrets are revealed that could change the course of the show's future.
After Mike forgets Jordan's birthday, he gives Jordan a junk bike to make up for it. This proves to be a problem when neither of them know how to ride it.
When Jordan's twin brother Gordon shows up abruptly, the two bond, but Mike believes Gordon is bringing bad things into Jordan's life. Gordon and Mike propose an ultimatum that Jordan must choose between the two of them.
Jordan discovers Mike shaving, and is upset that Mike has gone through puberty and he hasn't. Jordan tries to speed along the puberty process, giving Mike a chance to mess with him.
Mike discovers Jordan's awful dental hygiene, and forces Jordan to overcome his fear of going to the dentist. The laughing gas at the dentist's office seems to cancel out Jordan's craziness, and Mike gets sick of the new, boring, businessperson Jordan. Mike tries to bring back Jordan's crazy side.
Things at HTLBL may change for good when rival filmmaker James Derkiss (Alex Webster) threatens to take Jordan away from Mike.
After a heated argument, Mike and Jordan imagine a day in each other's shoes in this unfinished and lost episode.
Three months have passed since 'The Derkiss', and Mike and Jordan's lives are not what they had imagined.
Jordan and Mike feel uncomfortable with Ryan staying in the house, so they try to find a way to let him down gently.
Mike and Jordan get lost in the woods while celebrating a return to their status quo.
Jordan's sister, Summer, moves back from Canada, and Mike falls head over heels. After proving himself worthy, however, Mike's date does not go as planned.
Jordan joins an acting class, where he is introduced to Mr. Sycamore (an eccentric acting teacher), Wendy (a sweet girl who recognizes Jordan from West Side Story), and Brooke (an acting know-it-all who's been on TV and Broadway). He makes new friends and starts a class rivalry with Brooke. Meanwhile, Mike believes Jordan may be in a cult, and he and Summer try to figure out what's going on.
Jordan takes control of Mike's second date with Summer, as he believes the second date is the most important, but his involvement in their date may ruin their "relationship".
After Mr. Sycamore gets his hands on Mike's priceless birthday present to Jordan, Mike and Jordan let him be a part of their show to get it back.
Mike, Jordan, and Summer come together to discuss mortality and how to make the best of the time they have left, when one of their lives is at stake.
Mike tries to help Jordan woo over Wendy from his acting class, which actually succeeds. Jordan then invites Wendy on a date, which does not go according to plan.
Mike's stay in jail leads to he and Jordan not being very good boyfriends to Summer and Wendy, leading to conflict.
When Ryan and Derkiss return to town for a press conference in honor of Ryan's new celebrity and he and Derkiss' upcoming film, Jordan and Derkiss embark on an unlikely friendship, while Mike and Ryan try to find themselves.
Mike and Jordan's number one fan, PJ Lod, wins a contest to spend a day on the set, leading to complications.
Jordan leads Mike into believing that human civilization is coming to an end, leading to the two of them stuck together in a bomb shelter.
Jordan and Wendy take Mike to a Rocky Horror midnight showing to help him deal with a personal crisis, but getting stuck and missing the showing leads to drama, development, and singing for Mike, Jordan and Wendy.
Mike and Jordan's new band leads to conflict when Jordan starts experimenting with mind-altering breath mints.
Wendy finally watches the documentary, and asks Mike and Jordan to explain the many inconsistencies.
Mike enlists the help of Mr. Sycamore to keep up his facade of convincing Jordan that he's British.
Mike and Jordan try to solve problems for Ben, Hot Girl, Ryan, and Derkiss. Something is proposed to Mike and Jordan that will change everything.
Six months after turning the documentary cameras off, Mike and Jordan, along with some special guests, come out of their silence to give an update on where life has taken them.
