Gianni (The Basketball Star) gets a hall pass, and after waiting years, invites Loretta (The Dream Girl) for a romantic night on the beach. But when Jamie discovers the date has lasted all night and the two didn't sleep at the reunion house, Jamie flies into a rage. Back at the house, Carin (The Fat Girl) and Nikki (The head Cheerleader) have different memories of how Carin was treated in school and send her remembering all of her old feelings of being overnight and depressed; when Eze (The Soccer Guy) sees that Nikol and Jim are having problems getting close, he makes his move on her. Two new arrivals, sisters Tara (The Vixen) and Torie (The Hottie), arrive and turn the house into a party starting with a late night swim and a sexy game of truth or dare.